A tale of cats, spiritual leaders, a war on rats, and a baptism by fire hose. In other words, this is not your average cat story.
Archive for the ‘Cats in the Mews’ Category
1908: Haggerino the Harlem Tramp Cat of West 115th Street
Posted: 10th January 2026 by The Hatching Cat in Cat Stories, Cats in the MewsTags: Adolphus Bussing, Father Divine, Harlem history, King Towers, Sweet Daddy Grace
1
1893: A Crazy Cat Tale From Hart Street, Bushwick
Posted: 10th October 2025 by The Hatching Cat in Cat Stories, Cats in the MewsTags: Adolph H. Goetting, Bushwick, Cats of Old New York, Hart Street, Theodore Loeffler
Sometimes I find a ridiculously absurd story that isn’t specifically about a cat or dog or other animal, but I can’t resist sharing it. This crazy “cat tale” of New York City’s Gilded Age involves a two-family home on Hart Street in Bushwick, Brooklyn, a large hole in the ceiling, an even larger sabre, a bit of indecent exposure (for those days), a court hearing, a street chase, and a few cameo appearances by an unnamed cat.
1895: The Comical Court Case of Tommy, the Stolen Cat of East 41st Street
Posted: 25th April 2025 by The Hatching Cat in Cat Stories, Cats in the MewsTags: Anna Staubstaudt, Cats of Old New York, James Quackinbush, Murray Hill, New York City History, Robert Murray
Tommy was a cat of remarkable beauty, but he also had strong lungs and fighting qualities. Mrs. Hall acquired the cat in 1887, and though he often wandered the neighborhood looking to stir things up, he never strayed far from home. That is, until the summer of 1895.
1911: The Day it Rained Cats on Putnam Avenue in Bushwick, Brooklyn
Posted: 8th November 2024 by The Hatching Cat in Cat Stories, Cats in the MewsTags: Brooklyn History, Bushwick History, Cats of Old New York, Jacob Suydam, Leffert Lefferts
Every so often, I find an animal story of Old New York that is so silly or absurd, I start laughing out loud. I hope this following tale of a neighbor dispute on Putnam Avenue in Bushwick, Brooklyn will also leave you laughing.
1918: The Stray Cat That Saved 9+ Lives in a Peck Slip Lodging House
Posted: 10th September 2024 by The Hatching Cat in Cat Stories, Cats in the MewsTags: Cats of Old New York, Govert Loockermans, John Sigel, Lifesaving Cats, Peck Slip, William Beekman
John Sigel and his wife may not have wanted to add any more family members to their household in January 1918. But when their three children carried a freezing, starving waif cat into their small apartment at 1 Peck Slip, they couldn’t resist.
A story of a lifesaving cat, the history of Peck Slip, and a brief history of fire escapes in Old New York from my latest book, The Bravest Pets of Gotham: Tales of Four-Legged Firefighters of Old New York.
